Hula Hoop: The Toy Craze That Conquered the World
On March 5, 1963, Wham-O patented the Hula Hoop after selling 25 million in just two months. The toy craze swept the globe and even got banned in countries.
Read More
Oreo: The Copycat Cookie That Conquered the World
How a Knockoff Cookie Outsold the Original Forever
On March 6, 1912, a Hoboken grocer bought the very first Oreos ever sold. This copycat cookie outsold the original Hydrox and became the world's favorite.
Key Facts
First Sale Date
March 6, 1912
First Buyer
S.C. Thuesen, Hoboken grocer
Original Price
$1.85 for 9.25 pounds
Original Name
Oreo Biscuit
Manufacturer
National Biscuit Company (Nabisco)
Factory Location
Chelsea, New York City
Cookie It Copied
Hydrox (launched 1908)
Total Cookies Sold
Over 500 billion worldwide
Annual Production
40 billion cookies per year
Countries Sold In
Over 100 countries
Design Elements
12 flowers, 12 dots, 12 dashes
National Oreo Day
March 6 every year
About Oreo: The Copycat Cookie That Conquered the World
On March 6, 1912, a grocer named S.C. Thuesen in Hoboken, New Jersey placed the very first order for a cookie called the Oreo Biscuit. He paid $1.85 for nine and a quarter pounds of cookies, plus 50 cents for the tin. Nobody at Nabisco could have predicted that this humble sale would launch the most popular cookie on Earth.
The Cookie That Stole Someone Else's Idea
Oreo has a secret most fans never learn. The cookie was a knockoff. Sunshine Biscuits created the Hydrox cookie four years earlier in 1908. Nabisco built the Oreo as a direct competitor. Through better marketing and a sweeter filling, Oreo crushed Hydrox so thoroughly that people today think Hydrox copied Oreo.
The Forgotten Lemon Flavor Nobody Wanted
Nabisco launched two Oreo flavors on the same day in 1912. Alongside the classic chocolate cookie, they introduced a lemon meringue version. Customers overwhelmingly chose chocolate, and Nabisco quietly discontinued the lemon flavor by the 1920s.
A Design Mystery That Stumps Everyone
The embossed pattern on every Oreo contains exactly 12 flowers, 12 dots, and 12 dashes surrounding a two bar cross. Conspiracy theorists have linked the symbols to the Knights Templar and Freemasons. The designer's son settled the debate by explaining that his father simply thought flowers looked nice on a cookie.
How Twisting a Cookie Became a Cultural Ritual
In the 1940s, Nabisco turned eating into entertainment. The company promoted the "Twist, Lick, Dunk" method as the official way to enjoy an Oreo. Twisting the cookie open, licking the cream, and dunking it in milk transformed a simple snack into a shared childhood ritual that spans generations.
The Lard Secret That Lost Millions of Customers
For decades, Oreo's cream filling contained lard, making the cookie off limits for kosher consumers. Hydrox held the kosher market for 70 years because of this. Nabisco finally removed the lard and earned kosher certification, unlocking a massive new customer base almost a century after launch.
From One Grocer to 100 Countries
That single tin sold in Hoboken sparked a global cookie empire. Factories now produce over 40 billion Oreos every year for more than 100 countries. March 6 became National Oreo Cookie Day, celebrating that very first sale.
📊
Historical Analysis
⚡Historical Significance
- •
The Oreo launched on March 6, 1912, from Nabisco's Chelsea factory in New York City, marking the birth of what would become the best selling cookie in history
- •
The first sale to grocer S.C. Thuesen in Hoboken, New Jersey represents one of the most consequential small transactions in food industry history
- •
Nabisco modeled the Oreo after the Hydrox cookie from 1908, demonstrating how effective marketing can overtake an original product entirely
📝Critical Reception
- •
The chocolate version outsold the lemon meringue flavor so decisively that Nabisco discontinued lemon within a decade
- •
The Twist, Lick, Dunk eating ritual introduced in the 1940s transformed the Oreo from a simple cookie into an interactive experience
- •
Food scientists credit Sam Porcello's cream filling formula and the switch from lard to vegetable based ingredients as key turning points in the cookie's mass appeal
🌍Cultural Impact
- •
The Oreo transcended its role as a snack to become a cultural symbol recognized in over 100 countries worldwide
- •
The cookie inspired countless recipes, from Oreo cheesecake to milkshakes, creating an entire dessert subcategory
- •
National Oreo Cookie Day on March 6 generates massive annual social media engagement and brand celebrations
- •
The Oreo's design featuring 12 flowers, 12 dots, and 12 dashes spawned conspiracy theories connecting it to the Knights Templar and Freemasons
Before & After
📅Before
Before March 6, 1912, the chocolate sandwich cookie market belonged entirely to Hydrox, made by Sunshine Biscuits since 1908. Cookies served as simple pantry staples without brand rituals or cultural significance. No cookie company had yet figured out how to turn eating a snack into a shared experience or a lifestyle brand.
🚀After
After the Oreo launched, Nabisco proved that superior marketing could defeat an original product so completely that the copycat becomes the cultural standard. The Twist, Lick, Dunk ritual turned cookie eating into performance. Over 500 billion Oreos have sold worldwide, the brand operates in over 100 countries, and March 6 became a nationally recognized food holiday celebrating a cookie that started as an imitation.
💡
Did You Know?
•
Nabisco launched a lemon meringue Oreo in 1912 that flopped and disappeared by the 1920s.
•
Oreo cream filling contained lard for decades, making it off limits for kosher consumers.
•
The Oreo design features exactly 12 flowers, 12 dots, and 12 dashes on each cookie.
•
Hydrox fans still insist their 1908 original tastes better than the Oreo that copied it.
•
The very first Oreo order cost a Hoboken grocer $1.85 for the cookies plus 50 cents for the tin.
⭐
Why It Still Matters Today
•
Over 40 billion Oreos roll off production lines every year, making it one of the most manufactured food products on Earth
•
The Oreo vs Hydrox story remains a classic business case study in how marketing and distribution can defeat a first mover advantage
•
National Oreo Cookie Day on March 6 trends globally on social media every year, proving the cookie's enduring cultural relevance
•
Nabisco continues releasing experimental flavors from wasabi to hot chicken wing, keeping the brand culturally relevant with younger consumers
•
The Twist, Lick, Dunk ritual connects multiple generations through a shared food experience that transcends cultural boundaries
🧠
Test Your Knowledge
How much do you know? Take this quick quiz to find out!
1. What cookie did Nabisco copy when creating the Oreo in 1912?
2. What forgotten Oreo flavor launched alongside the original in 1912?
💎
Original Insights
•
Oreo's cream filling originally contained lard, which locked the cookie out of the kosher market for nearly 70 years while rival Hydrox dominated that segment
•
Nabisco launched a lemon meringue Oreo on the exact same day as the chocolate version in 1912, but almost nobody remembers it existed
•
The Oreo embossing design sparked Freemason and Knights Templar conspiracy theories, but the designer's son confirmed his father just liked how flowers looked
•
Hydrox actually tasted less sweet than Oreo, and dedicated fans argue the original recipe remains superior to the cookie that replaced it in popular culture
•
The very first Oreo order totaled just $2.35, including the tin, yet that single transaction launched a brand now worth billions
Frequently Asked Questions
Nabisco (the National Biscuit Company) created the Oreo Biscuit in 1912 at their Chelsea, New York City factory. The company modeled it after the Hydrox cookie, which Sunshine Biscuits had introduced four years earlier in 1908. Nabisco never publicly credited Hydrox as the inspiration.
This article is reviewed by the Pagefacts team.
Editorial Approach:
This article reveals the untold story behind the Oreo: how Nabisco copied the Hydrox cookie and outsold the original so completely that history reversed the narrative, the forgotten lemon meringue flavor that launched the same day, the lard ingredient that locked Oreo out of the kosher market for 70 years, and the cookie design that accidentally spawned Freemason conspiracy theories.
More from Today In History
Explore more fascinating facts in this category
PlayStation 2: The Console That Won Everything
On March 4, 2000, Sony launched the PlayStation 2 in Japan. It became the best selling video game console of all time with over 155 million units sold.
Read More
Nintendo Switch Launch: The Console That Saved Nintendo
On March 3, 2017, Nintendo launched the Switch after the disastrous Wii U era. It became the fastest selling console in Nintendo history and a gaming sensation.
Read More